The 10 Biggest Mistakes I Made As An Online Course Creator

Written By Melvin VargheseMelvin Varghese PhD

Creating an online course has changed my life.

It’s allowed me to build a life around my family, focus on my health, and step back from the therapy chair.

But it wasn’t always easy.
And along the way, I made a lot of mistakes.

Today, I’m sharing an encore of my podcast epsiode with the top 10 lessons I’ve learned over the past 7 years of building, tweaking, and growing my first digital course.

Whether you're dreaming up your first course or looking to refine one that’s already live, I hope these lessons save you time, energy, and heartache.

Mistake #1: Letting Trauma Set My Pricing

I didn’t realize how much my childhood trauma — and immigrant upbringing — shaped my pricing mindset.

I felt like I had to “prove” myself.
So I priced my course way too low.

Even after I hit big milestones — podcast charts, student testimonials — I still struggled to believe I was worth charging more.

That underpricing led to:

  • Poor revenue growth

  • Anxiety + burnout

  • Feeling resentful

Lesson: Your trauma may be driving your money story. Start doing the inner work early — therapy, brainspotting, books, and communities can all help.

📚 Try:

Mistake #2: Lifetime Coaching + Community Access

I threw the kitchen sink into the course offer because I was afraid people would ask for refunds.

But offering lifetime access to:

  • Group coaching

  • Community support

…quickly became unsustainable.

Over time, it led to burnout and resentment because I was still showing up for students years after their purchase — often for a one-time $500 sale.

Lesson: Define clear access boundaries. Coaching and community should match your pricing — and your energy capacity.

Mistake #3: Obsessing Over Gear, Not Marketing

I spent more time researching mics than building a marketing system.

Why? Because marketing felt scary.

What changed my mindset:
Marketing is connection. Marketing is service.

Once I saw it that way, I focused on being helpful — and chose one platform (Twitter) to go all in on.

Lesson: Start with one product and one marketing channel. Then show up consistently.

Mistake #4: Trying to Be “Middle of the Pack”

I priced my course like everyone else — trying to stay “affordable.”

But I wasn’t thinking like a business owner.

A friend asked:
“Do you want to be Apple or Walmart in your niche?”

It shifted everything.
Now, I aim to go deep with a smaller number of high-fit students — and charge accordingly.

Mistake #5: Ignoring the Backend Opportunity

I thought a course was one-and-done.

I didn’t realize a good course can lead to:

  • Retreats

  • Masterminds

  • Intensives

  • Group coaching

  • Recurring membership

Lesson: Not everyone wants more… but some of your best students do. Build with that in mind.

Mistake #6: Chasing Sales Instead of Testimonials

Every sale felt like a rush.

But I wasn’t asking myself:
“How do I use this momentum to grow future sales?”

Eventually I learned: a good testimonial is better than a short-term dopamine hit.

Now we collect testimonials every 3–4 months, using a storytelling framework that highlights:

  • Before → After transformation

  • Tangible outcomes

  • Emotional wins

Mistake #7: Building a “Strip Mall” Instead of a “Skyscraper”

In the early days, I had multiple products (a.k.a. strip mall model).

But it was exhausting:

  • Constant updates

  • Multiple funnels

  • More decision fatigue

Now I’m shifting to a skyscraper model — one core offer (my mastermind), with deep value and long-term growth.

Lesson: More offers ≠ better business. One great product done well can scale better than five average ones.

Mistake #8: Thinking I Couldn’t Teach Because Someone Else Was

When I wanted to create a podcasting course, I hesitated.

Why?
Because my mentor already had one.

But here’s what I learned:
There’s room for all of us — especially when you niche down.

My course? It’s not for everyone.
It’s specifically for therapists, with a focus on heart-centered podcasting. That makes it unique.

Mistake #9: Selling Over Serving

Early on, I focused too much on closing the sale.

But I’ve learned something powerful:
The relationship matters more than the sale.

People forget your product.
But they remember how you made them feel.

In my recent mastermind launch, I said no to 13 amazing people because I didn’t feel it was the right fit — and that’s a boundary I’m proud of.

Mistake #10: No Recurring Revenue

I focused too much on single sales, not sustainability.

Now, I pair:

  • ✅ One-time course sales

  • ♻️ Recurring offers (like a monthly mastermind)

That combo gives me stability and the ability to reinvest in quality.

Final Thoughts

You don’t have to make these mistakes.
And if you’ve already made some — that’s okay.

Every “wrong” turn has taught me more about what kind of business I actually want to build.

One that’s grounded in:

  • Integrity

  • Energy alignment

  • Deep relationships

  • Quiet growth

If you're a therapist thinking about creating an online course, I’ve created a free A-to-Z guide to help.

It includes:

  • Software recs

  • Loom walkthroughs

  • The 10 most common course questions (with video answers)

📥 Download the free guide here →

selling the couch podcast with melvin varghese phd

Weekly interviews, strategy, and advice for building your private practice in and beyond the therapy room.  

ready to launch your online course?

Please check out our free online course starter kit for therapists (and therapists turned coaches and consultants). 

This FREE 7-day email course will help you validate your course idea (so that you can create a course that has buyers). 

ready to launch your podcast?

Please check out our FREE podcasting workshop for therapists (and therapists turned coaches and consultants). 

This workshop is pre-recorded so you can watch it on a day and time that works for your schedule. 

It contains a lot of practical tips that we've learned as STC has reached 1.81 million+ downloads and become a 6-figure business with podcasting as the backbone. 

a photo of Melvin Varghhese PhD sitting at a desk with a podcasting mic in front of him.

Melvin varghese phd

Psychologist and Founder @ Selling The Couch 

Melvin Varghese, PhD is a licensed psychologist in Philadelphia, PA.  In 2015, Dr. Varghese founded Selling The Couch, a podcast to help therapists move from clinical to online income.  On the podcast, he interviews successful practitioners about how they've built their practices, social media/marketing experts, and shares lessons as he uses our clinical skills to create an online business powered by podcasting + online courses.

The podcast is one of the top Career podcasts in Apple Podcasts, has been downloaded over 1.8 million times, and is heard in over 125 countries. Mel is a successful course creator with 240+ students and $300k+ in course sales.

More Posts

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.